Meinrath: Net Neutrality - 10 Points
In a recent email, Sasha Meinrath (CUWIN), offers a 10 point synopsis from a draft paper on Network Neutrality.
Sasha Meinrath is the director of CUWIN, one of the most advanced
wireless initiatives in the country (at UIUC), recently receiving
$500,000 funding from NSF. His paper on Net Neutrality also
applies to 'open' fiber nets.
rl
---------- Forwarded message ----------
Date: Fri, 25 Aug 2006 11:48:08 -0500
From: Sascha Meinrath <[email protected]>
To: Richard Lowenberg <[email protected]>
Subject: The New Network Neutrality: Criteria for Internet Freedom
(Looking for Feedback).
Hi Richard,
Attached is a paper Victor Pickard and I wrote for the upcoming TPRC
conference.
The next draft is due on the 31st and we're looking for feedback from
knowledgeable folks. I fully expect that this is going to be a
controversial piece -- but I think it lays down a strong case for going
well beyond current conceptualizations of Network Neutrality.
In a nutshell the Meinrath & Pickard New Network Neutrality contains ten points:
1. Requires Common Carriage.
2. Is Open Architecture and Supports Open Source Driver
Development.
3. Is Open Protocol and Open Standard.
4. Supports an End-to-End Architecture (i.e., is composed of a dumb
network).
5. Is Private (e.g., no back doors, deep packet inspection,
etc.).
6. Is Application-Neutral.
7. Is Low-Latency and First-In/First-Out (i.e., requires adequate
capacity for both).
8. Is Interoperable.
9. Is Business Model Neutral.
10. Is Run by its Users (i.e., is internationally representative and
non-Amerocentric).
Thanks for your help,
Sascha
Sascha Meinrath
Executive Director Principal President
CUWiN; The Ethos Group; Acorn Active Media
CUWireless.Net
EthosWireless.com
AcornActiveMedia.com